HSI Locksmith gold shield logoHSI LocksmithLicensed & Insured · Mobile (561) 366-2611Call Now

Home › Guides › Rekey vs. Replace

Rekey vs. Replace: Which Does Your Lock Actually Need?

Rekeying changes who can open your lock; replacing changes the lock. They solve different problems, at different sizes of job — and a good locksmith will talk you out of the wrong one.

Need this handled?

Enter your city or ZIP and we’ll open the matching local page — or call and describe it.

We couldn’t match that entry to a service area page. Call or text and we’ll confirm coverage for your exact spot:

Call (561) 366-2611 Text (561) 405-1395

Tell us what happened — tap your situation

Pick a situation, then add your city or ZIP above and tap Find — if your location is already entered, we’ll route you immediately.

What rekeying does

Inside the cylinder, pins are matched to a key’s cuts. Rekeying repins the cylinder to a new key: the lock, the door and the finish stay, and every copy of the old key stops working. It answers the question ‘who out there has a key?’ — completely, for every door rekeyed.

Rekeying is the right job when access control is the problem and the hardware is healthy: move-ins, turnovers, lost keys, changed relationships, new staff. The move-in case is detailed in our move-in guide.

Rekey vs. Replace: Which Does Your Lock Actually Need?

What replacement adds

Replacement answers a different question: ‘is this lock itself good enough?’ New hardware makes sense when the lock is worn or failing, when parts no longer exist, when you want a higher grade or restricted-keyway security, or when you’re changing the entry style entirely — to a smart lock, say.

Replacement also fixes mismatched doors: a house that accumulated four brands and three keys over thirty years can come out of one visit on a single key.

The honest test

Run two questions per door. Does the lock work perfectly? If not, replacement (or repair) is on the table. Do I know everyone who holds its key? If not, rekeying is mandatory regardless. Plenty of doors need only the second answer acted on — and any locksmith who skips the questions and quotes all-new hardware for every door is answering a question you didn’t ask.

Call (561) 366-2611 and describe your doors; we’ll tell you which side of the line each one is on before you book.

How this article connects

Locks change, lock rekey, lock replaced — which job is yours?

A locks change and a lock rekey are the same routine with different words: the hardware stays, every old key stops working. A lock replaced is the other side of the decision — new hardware when the lock itself is worn, damaged, or due an upgrade. Our rekey vs. replace guide walks the choice door by door.

Residential · Rekeying — Questions

Straight answers.

Is a rekeyed lock as secure as a new one?

Against old keys, identically secure — the old key simply stops existing as far as the lock is concerned. New hardware adds value when the old lock is worn or low-grade.

Can some doors be rekeyed and others replaced?

That’s the most common outcome, honestly — each door gets what it needs, and everything can still end up on one key.

How many keys do I get with a rekey?

As many as you ask for — cut on the spot during the visit. We suggest one per adult, a safe spare, and a counted set for lending.

Need a Locksmith?

One call and your appointment is set.

Phones answered around the clock, every day of the year.